Amanda Hodge adds twist to Dayan Anthony’s tale

Amanda Hodge in The Weekend Australian, 28-29 July 2012 where the title reads: “Deported Tamil recants tales of torture”

 DAYAN ANTHONY–GoSL Pic not that of the Australian

EXHAUSTED and showing the strain of a horror week of deportation and interrogation, Dayan Anthony presented just the sobering warning he was intended to be as he fronted a Sri Lankan government media conference to warn of the repercussions of asylum-seeking. In sweat top and pants, his eyes red and hooded with fatigue after 16 hours of questioning, he told a sparse gathering of journalists: “Don’t believe what agents say. You get tempted when people tell stories in Australia about how you can get rich but the boys who go over there will return in handcuffs. “I want to tell Tamils registered as asylum-seekers in Australia they can safely return because I also returned.”

It could not have been scripted better had it been written by the best propagandists of the Australian or Sri Lankan governments. In the federal government’s war on people-smuggling, Mr Anthony is a serious shot across the bows of the king pins, whose message that hope and opportunity is a mere boat ride away has gained traction in the trouble zones of South Asia.

 Asylum seekers–Pic from Daily Telegraph

Mr Anthony became the first Tamil asylum-seeker to be deported from Australia since the end of the island nation’s 27-year civil conflict when he arrived at Colombo airport at 12.45am on Thursday and was handed to Sri Lankan immigration officials. Less than 24 hours later he had been released from police custody to face the media, where he publicly recanted all claims of torture and mistreatment by Sri Lankan authorities and confessed he had lied to Australian officials, UN representatives and refugee advocates in order to obtain a refugee visa.

He also insisted he had been treated well by Sri Lankan police since his arrival, despite the fears of his Melbourne-based sister and brother-in-law and refugee advocates that his life would be in danger if he was returned to Sri Lanka. In an interview with The Weekend Australian, conducted afterwards in an empty Colombo restaurant in the presence of a senior Defence Ministry official who, we were told, was helping him find accommodation, Mr Anthony insisted he was “OK” and “a free man”.

“I had an Australian dream. I came here in fear but now I feel OK,” he said. “I feel Sri Lanka is safe now. War is over. I don’t think anything will happen to me.” A spokeswoman for Immigration Minister Chris Bowen said Mr Anthony was not being held by Sri Lankan authorities and his situation continued to be monitored. The government returned Mr Anthony last Wednesday — ignoring an 11th-hour attempt by the UN Human Rights Commissioner to stop his deportation in Bangkok — saying he had exhausted all legal and ministerial avenues in a 27-month campaign for refugee status.

He denied he had been pressured to recant, but the Australian Tamil community has warned there is something strange about his decision to renounce his past claims of torture at the hands of the Sri Lankan government. Australia Tamil Congress spokesman Bala Vigneswaran said he was concerned Mr Anthony may have been coached by Sri Lankan authorities during his marathon interrogation. “They coach people before they put people to public media,” he said. “It should look obvious to normal thinking people, that this sounds fishy.

“When you read through the lines, you can see there are issues. And why would you need 16 hours for interrogation, if the person is making up stories?”

Refugee Action Coalition spokesman Ian Rintoul also expressed scepticism: “I think it’s fairly clear that any recantation is a result of duress.” Mr Anthony, 30, had claimed to have been kidnapped and tortured in 2009 after he was seized and thrown into the back of one of Sri Lanka’s notorious white vans used in disappearances.

He also complained of severe back pain from beatings sustained in Sri Lankan custody — a diagnosis supported by a Melbourne specialist — and gave evidence to the UN special rapporteur on torture late last year. Before his deportation he was receiving treatment for mental health issues.

Asked about his conditions, he told The Weekend Australian: “I don’t have a back problem. I don’t have psychological problems. I’m OK. I feel OK. When I was flying here I felt I would be tortured and beaten up but I am OK. “There’s a fear psychosis that’s created that when you come to Sri Lanka you will be hung up and beaten. But I was taken to the (Colombo CID’s notorious) fourth floor and given a cup of tea.”

Mr Anthony said he had been advised by a Malaysian Tamil people-smuggling agent, who arranged the forged passport for his April 2010 flight to Melbourne, to tell Australian officials he had been kidnapped in a white van and that he had links with the vanquished Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam. “The agent told me if I said that they would give me a visa. Everybody was fleeing to go to Australia. A lot of people lied to get the visa. People come with hope because people-smugglers say they will get visas but nothing happens.” He said Australia’s swelling ranks of Sri Lankan asylum-seekers should return voluntarily, rather than be forced back in handcuffs as he had been, and offered a swollen wrist as evidence he had been roughed up by Australian immigration officials.

“The Australian authorities behaved very badly. Even though they’re signed to international human rights (agreements) they did this to me. They put me in handcuffs. They did not allow me any fax or phone because otherwise I would contact people. They wanted to send me as an example,” he said.

“There’s no justice in Australia. This is just a political problem for them. This will happen to every person. They will interview and reject you. In future they will deport a lot more asylum-seekers in handcuffs. I feel Australia are (sic) racists and still it is for white Australians only.”

When asked what the future held for him, the former textiles trader admitted he had no concrete plans beyond “sleeping for 5000 hours” and finding a job — perhaps abroad. “The future for everybody is suspicious,” he said. “Tomorrow we don’t know what will happen.”

Web Editor’s Initial Comments: While more extended essays will follow let me present short notes in point form.

  1. Yes this was a governmental propaganda exercise. More precisely it was a counter-propaganda exercise to that mounted by the Tamil lobby, the HR advocacy groups in Australia and the Aussie media acting in concert. It is an act of prejudice and conceit to think that the detested Enemy Other is the only side that indulges in “propaganda” — deployed here as dirty word.
  2. From the point of view of news marketing and sensational stories Hodge and The Australian are in a win-win situation. They are running with both the hounds and the hares; but in this instance their seeming fairness is interlaced with barbs that reveal they are with the hounds, viz Tamil lobby, their HR allies and media allies.
  3. The façade of fairness is also undermined by inaccuracies — whether deliberate twists or errors I cannot say.
  4. Canberra embassy and Defence Ministry sources indicate that Anthony landed just after midnight on the Wednesday/Thursday night (?) and that it is erroneous to say that he was subject to sixteen hours of questioning. (A) In standard procedure for deportees he was initially questioned by the Immigration personnel and (B) kept in a rest room at the airport –where presumably he could sleep and would receive basic victuals. (C) Late that morning he was taken to the CID fourth floor and questioned while the authorities ascertained whether he had been cited in any police or intelligence warrants. (D) Since he had not been identified in their radar for “terrorism” and crimes, he was then free man but was also presented to the press in the government’s counter-propaganda exercise. This was around 4.45 that evening. A video of that session has been presented by the Daily Mirror and readers are encouraged to view it at Anthony speaks here in Sinhala with an occasional English commentary (and his colloquial Sinhala is inflected with English words in the fashion common within Sinhala-speak. Examples are: “hora passport” and “sudhu van”).
  5.  I am not in a position to say whether that video has been edited; but at face value it does not reveal a man who is wholly exhausted. Nor does it suggest duress.
  6. He may, of course, be seeking to curry favour with the government.
  7. It has also been suggested that Dayan Anthony was coached by the SL personnel as part of their propaganda exercise. That is possible … but, then, he was coached by the illegal smuggling racketeer of Malaysian-Tamil nationality (presumably part of an old LTTE network?)  “to tell Australian officials he had been kidnapped in a white van and that he had links with the vanquished Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam” (quoting Hodge’s report here).
  8. It appears, then, that from the insulated Australian HR and media perspective that coaching and propaganda is only indulged in by the Bad Guys!  There is more than a touch here of the ideological strands described by Edward Said as “Orientalism.”
  9. A small error: Anthony is not the first Tamil deported from Australia. Sometime in 2010 the previous SL ambassador Senaka Walgampaya [whom I met at a dinner in Adelaide] sent me the statistics of Sri Lankans sent back on one way visas in the previous 18 months or so. My Hotmail account is compromised and I cannot recoup the details; but from memory there had been about 90 sent back with about 80 being Sinhalese, five Tamil and five Muslim. This figure is subject to adjustment.

PS: 10. The video clip presented by the Daily Mirror, I have been told, has edited a 15 minute press Q and A session to 5 minutes. So what seems to be a rambling, continuous tale by Anthony is really a response to questions. It is nevertheless a valuable document. It can also be studied at  and hopefully will contain translations in Tamil and English.


Filed under accountability, asylum-seekers, australian media, discrimination, disparagement, historical interpretation, immigration, life stories, LTTE, politIcal discourse, propaganda, Rajapaksa regime, reconciliation, Sinhala-Tamil Relations, sri lankan society, tamil refugees, world events & processes

27 responses to “Amanda Hodge adds twist to Dayan Anthony’s tale

  1. I do prefer editor’s comments to the way that the Australian wrote the story.

    As most people may be aware asylum seekers have become a hot issue in Australia. There has been a complete collapse of border security for boat arrivals. As a result deportees will be turned into a mixture of activist and media fodder.

  2. Psara

    Amanda Hodge gets rare access to a caught Tamil asylum seeker who says federal government action is not a deterrent.

  3. Pingback: Again! Two Significant items in THE AUSTRALIAN on asylum seeker issues | Thuppahi's Blog

  4. Pingback: A Flourishing Bibliographical Tree: Tamil Migration, Asylum-Seekers and Australia | Thuppahi's Blog

  5. Pingback: Deported From Britain: Back To Ordinariness Or ‘Duress’ In Sri Lanka? | Colombo Telegraph

  6. Pingback: Deported from Britain: back to ‘duress’ or ordinariness in Sri Lanka? | Thuppahi's Blog

  7. Pingback: Rohan Gunaratna on people smuggling entworks and migration impulses | Thuppahi's Blog

  8. Pingback: “Island of tears and fears” – says Hodge | Thuppahi's Blog

  9. Pingback: Alex Kuhendrarajah, where are you? Lessons to be learnt by Australian media | Thuppahi's Blog

  10. Pingback: High Court judgment pending on Tamils deemed security risks | Thuppahi's Blog

  11. Pingback: Australia! Australia! Land of Hope and Fantasy for Tamil Refugees in India | Thuppahi's Blog

  12. Pingback: Different Photographs in The Weekend Australian: Implications | Thuppahi's Blog

  13. Pingback: Asylum Seekers from Lanka: No Solutions in Sight | Thuppahi's Blog

  14. Pingback: Turning back the boats helps stem the Sri Lankan tide. Is this part of the solution for Australia? | Thuppahi's Blog

  15. Pingback: Twenty Väddas and Thuppahies deported to Sri Lanka from Australia? | Thuppahi's Blog

  16. Pingback: Migrant Remittances drive “Asylum-Seeker” Out-Migration from Sri Lanka | Thuppahi's Blog

  17. Pingback: Sheridan buys into GL Peiris’s Contentions | Thuppahi's Blog

  18. Pingback: Ahoy! A Ship! A Ship! The BOATS in the asylum-seeker brouhaha | Thuppahi's Blog

  19. Pingback: Moral immaturity befuddles the humanitarians on the asylum-seeker issue | Thuppahi's Blog

  20. Pingback: Rajapaksa government fighting to win the peace | Thuppahi's Blog

  21. Pingback: Torture of ex-Asylum-Seekers in Lanka: SBS, Corlett and Sooka train their gunsights on Sri Lanka | Thuppahi's Blog

  22. Pingback: Torture ‘Clinics’ in UK as Pathway to Asylum? | Thuppahi's Blog

  23. Pingback: Gunasekera vs SBS: Mahinda from Canada places Corlett’s Dateline Video and SMH Report in Context | Thuppahi's Blog

  24. Pingback: Disappearances and Torture in Lanka, 2009-16: A Bibliography | Thuppahi's Blog

  25. Pingback: A Sob Story? Hodge in Batticaloa batting for the Nadeshalingam Family | Thuppahi's Blog

Leave a Reply