A Measured View on the Halal Controversy in Sri Lanka

ACL Ameer Ali, courtesy of the Sri Lanka Guardian

Ameer Ali Halal picThe Arabic word halal simply means permissible and is the direct opposite of haram meaning prohibited. In between these two extremes there are several shades of permissibility and prohibition, and in none of which, including the two extremities, there is unanimity of opinion among Muslim religious scholars. This categorization in cover not only the narrow field of food and drinks but also the vast terrain of personal and societal behaviour and actions, such as economic transactions, social interaction, national governance, and so on. There are a number of contradictory and conflicting fatwas or religious rulings in relation to each of them. However, the bottom line is that they are all meant for Muslims and to Muslims only. Even in Muslim countries like Malaysia and Indonesia non-Muslims are not compelled to consume halal food. For example, the Chinese in these countries are allowed to produce, consume, and trade in pork and pork related products even though such products are declared haram in Islam and even though some extremist Muslim groups would prefer them to be prohibited in the name of shariah laws. Hence, in Sri Lanka or anywhere else if any one forces a Buddhist or a Hindu or a Christian to eat halal food that action itself will tantamount to haram. Continue reading

Leave a comment

Filed under cultural transmission, discrimination, politIcal discourse, Rajapaksa regime, sri lankan society, tolerance, world events & processes

Sinhalaness and its Reproduction, 1232-1818

 Michael Roberts reproduced from Asanga Welikala (ed.) The Sri Lankan Republic at Forty: Reflections on Constitutional History, Theory and Practice, Colombo, Centre for Policy Alternatives, 2012, Volume I, pp. 253-87………….. ISBN 078-955-1655-93-8

I address the issue of Sinhala identity over time[1] with a focus on the period 1232-1818, the middle period as I shall call it in order to escape from European periodization. This periodization begins with the decline of the Polonnaruva civilisation and the shift of the principal Sinhala kingdoms to the hill country and south west; and ends, quite deliberately, with what has usually been termed (misleadingly) as “the Kandyan Rebellion” of 1817-18.[2] Within this broad span of time the emphasis is on the period 1400-1818. The analysis has an eye on the subsequent re-working of the Sinhala sentiments displayed in the rebellion during the nineteenth and twentieth centuries as a result of the processes of capitalist transformation and modernization in a world era marked by the consolidation of nation-states.

Pl 24 Adigar processionAddressing such a large span of time involving a substantial scholarly literature which has had to cope with mere fragments of source material for certain stages and localities poses a methodological problem of generalization. Conclusions must necessarily be cautious and suggestive. The definitive hues permeating some statements that follow are subject to this preliminary caveat. Continue reading

6 Comments

Filed under British colonialism, cultural transmission, ethnicity, historical interpretation, Indian Ocean politics, law of armed conflict, life stories, patriotism, politIcal discourse, power politics, sri lankan society, world events & processes

Free Speech meets Hate-Speech in Australia

Editorial in THE AUSTRALIAN, entitled ‘Peace’ talkfest needs scrutiny

OUR free, democratic society thrives on robust political debate, which is why speakers at this weekend’s Australian Islamic Peace Conference in Melbourne are entitled to their say in the public square.  Organisers of the so-called peace conference displayed a bizarre sense of irony, however, in promoting the event as “the LARGEST, the BIGGEST and the BEST EVER Islamic Event in the History of Australia” with an advertised speakers’ list headed by the Imam of Mecca, Abdul Rahman al-Sudais. A bigoted proponent of jihad, the imam has called for the annihilation of Jews as “infidels, falsifiers of words, calf worshippers, prophet murderers, deniers of prophecies … the scum of the human race, accursed by Allah, who turned them into apes and pigs”. Continue reading

Leave a comment

Filed under accountability, Australian culture, australian media, fundamentalism, politIcal discourse, tolerance, world affairs

Against Hate Speech and Graffiti directed at Our Muslim Brethren: FRIDAY FORUM addresses President Rajapaksa

President Mahinda Rajapaksa,
President of Sri Lanka,
Presidential Secretariat,
Janadhipathi Mawatha,
Colombo 1.
7th March 2013.
Anti-Muslim Hate Campaign: The Government Must Act Decisively
Dear President Rajapaksa,
The Friday Forum urges you to act immediately and decisively to counter the increasingly venomous and strident anti-Muslim hate campaign launched by a few extremist groups claiming to represent the majority Sinhala community. As you are aware, this campaign has intensified over the past several months. The country has witnessed attacks against mosques, and the circulation, on social media, public posters and web-sites, of obscene and vituperative messages that are offensive to religious beliefs. It has witnessed anti-Muslim public rallies and processions, including a call to boycott Muslim business establishments.

MAHARA MOSQUE VANDALISED Mahara mosque – 03rd March Mahara mosque – vandalised Continue reading

Leave a comment

Filed under accountability, communal relations, cultural transmission, Muslims in Lanka, politIcal discourse, power politics, Rajapaksa regime, sri lankan society, tolerance, violence of language

Marakkala Kolahālaya: Mentalities directing the Pogrom of 1915

Michael Roberts

2a-Moorman Tamby =213This article is a reprint of chapter 8 in Roberts, Exploring Confrontation, Reading: Harwood, 1994 which inturn was re-printed with the above title in ROBERTS, CONFRONTATIONS IN SRI LANKA,  Colombo, Vijitha Yapa Publications, 2009 ISBN 978-955-665-035-8

Introduction: Categorical Clarifications1

In the course of 9-10 days in May-June 1915 segments of the Sinhala population drawn from a wide occupational spectrum systematically attacked the property and at times the person of Mohammedan Moors residing in the south western quadrant of the island—a region containing the majority of Sri Lanka’s population at that point of time. This event has since been referred to in Sinhala as the marakkala kolahālaya and in the English rendering as “the 1915 riots” or “the communal riots of 1915.” Because disputes in front of mosques are known to have been one of the reasons for these “riots”, it has been interpreted as a “religious conflict” between Muslims and Buddhists (Nissan & Stirrat 1990: 31-32; Spencer 1990: 5, 8). By itself, this characterisation is misleading and a corrective is in order.

52-Muslim men prepare for worshipThose whom we refer today in Sri Lankan English as “Muslim” were described till about the 1930s as “Mohammedan.” “Mohammedan” (or Muslim) takes its meaning from its context of usage. In juxtaposition with the categories Burgher, Sinhalese, Tamil, Malay, it is an ethnic label. Where aligned in distinction from Hindus, Buddhists and Christians, it is a religious category. It therefore carries a duality of meaning. This dual-sidedness is accentuated by the Sinhala usage. The Sinhala word, marakkala (Moor), is often used to refer to Mohammedans as well. Though there is ambiguity on this point, marakkala does not, unlike the English word “Mohammedan” (Muslim), usually encompass the (Malays). Indeed, the more erudite Sinhala word for Moors is yon (yona) in distinction from javun, javo, ja. Continue reading

7 Comments

Filed under communal relations, economic processes, historical interpretation, life stories, Muslims in Lanka, nationalism, politIcal discourse, power politics, sri lankan society

Pukerangi !! A quaint little railway station in South Island, New Zealand

OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERA OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERA

The Taieri Gorge railway run is presented as one of the the world’s “great train trips” and apart from the striking ‘gorgic’ scenery one meets several little railway stations of yesteryear that are as charming as extraordinary. For Sri Lankans with a penchant for awkward phonetic connotaiiosns when one crosses language divides, of course, Pukey-Ran-Gi will draw a laugh.

This is one of the other stations:

OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERA OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERA Continue reading

Leave a comment

Filed under cultural transmission, heritage, life stories, pulling the leg

Halal logo withdrawn! Hurrah! Hurrah! Harihara!

Rasika Somarathna, in the Daily News, 12 March 2013

halal agreement

The All Ceylon Jamiyyathul Ulama (ACJU) which has been issuing the Halal certification to businesses, said yesterday it decided to withdraw the Halal logo from all local products. However, companies may continue to obtain the Halal certification for their products on a voluntary basis to facilitate exports etc, and such certifiction will be issued free of charge by the ACJU, according to the Ceylon Chamber of Commerce (CCC). Continue reading

Leave a comment

Filed under accountability, communal relations, cultural transmission, fundamentalism, patriotism, power politics, power sharing, pulling the leg, reconciliation, sri lankan society, tolerance, world affairs

Marakkala Kolahālaya: Contemporary and Secondary Literature on the Anti-Moor Pogrom of 1915

Compiled by Michael Roberts to assist present-day debates on Sinhala -Muslim tensions …with RED identifying contemporary material

p163

Abdul Rahiman, W. M. 1915 Letter from WM Abdul Rahiman to Sir Robert Chalmers [Governor], 1 July 1915, in Colonial Office 54/782.

 Ameer Ali, A. C. L. 1981 “The 1915 racial riots in Ceylon (Sri Lanka): a reappraisaof its causes,” South Asia 4: 1-20.

Amunugama, Sarath 1978 “John de Silva and the Sinhala nationalist theatre,” Ceylon Historical Journal 25: 285-304. Continue reading

7 Comments

Filed under atrocities, British colonialism, British imperialism, communal relations, cultural transmission, economic processes, historical interpretation, life stories, politIcal discourse, riots and pogroms, sri lankan society, tolerance, violence of language

The Symposium on VILLAGE IN THE JUNGLE at Oxford: A Brief Report

Dominic Davies as Symposium Facilitator

This Day Symposium, hosted by the Oxford Centre for Life-Writing at Wolfson College, Oxford, marked and celebrated the centenary of the publication of Leonard Woolf’s path-breaking first novel, set in then Ceylon, The Village in the Jungle (1913). It explored the novel from a number of different critical and informed angles, all of which addressed and emphasized its richness, complexity and importance as a piece of literature. The Symposium was well attended, with over 60 delegates engaging with the various presentations, lectures and papers in the rich discussions that followed them.

SAMSUNG Continue reading

1 Comment

Filed under heritage, historical interpretation, life stories, literary achievements, self-reflexivity, sri lankan society, world affairs

Tamil IDPs Today and Yesterday… Pudukuduyirippu and Beyond

Michael Roberts hijacking Dhaneshi Yatawara

I: Preamble by Michael Roberts

Dhaneshi Yatawara is a Sri Lankan reporter whom I do not know and have no contact with. I happened to be in Sri Lanka in April-June 2009 and collected news clippings, which now guide me to items on web. Among the latter are a series of striking photographs provided by Dhaneshi Yatawara on the 10th and 17th May 2009 respectively. The first lot were obviously (though not so stated) snapped on the foreshores in the Pulmoddai or Trinco area as Tamil IDPs injured and “carers” were disembarked from ICRC ships guided by the SL Navy. Parenthetically I note here between the 10th February and 15th May 2009 the ICRC ships “Green Ocean” and “Seruvila” escorted by the SL Navy made several trips and evacuated “over 13,500 sick and wounded people and their caretakers” (http://www.icrc.org/eng/resources/ documents/ update/sri-lanka-update-090609.htm).[1]

60c-april 2009 exodus This Pic is not from Yatawara Continue reading

2 Comments

Filed under accountability, citizen journalism, economic processes, historical interpretation, IDP camps, life stories, LTTE, military expenditure, military strategy, politIcal discourse, power politics, propaganda, Rajapaksa regime, reconciliation, rehabilitation, Sinhala-Tamil Relations, sri lankan society, Tamil civilians, tamil refugees, tolerance, truth as casualty of war, welfare & philanthophy, women in ethnic conflcits, world events & processes