Category Archives: life stories

Free Speech, Hate Speech and Double Standards

Michael O’Leary aka Padraig Colman, courtesy of The Nation, 4 August 2013, where the title is “Freedom of Expression

fre sppechA number of fallacies are common in the blogosphere. A lot of people cannot cope with, or even understand, disagreement. Americans bloggers are fond of citing the First Amendment to the US Constitution. If someone disagrees with them, they complain that they are being silenced. Genuine disagreement is often described as “whining”. On Colombo Telegraph and Groundviews, there have been demands for me to be silenced. Inoka Karu called on GV to root out the “rabble-rousers”. “Dear moderators: I am repeatedly appealed to you to control hellion characters such ‘off the cuff’, Padraig Colman and J Fernando.”

More  disturbing was a call for suppression of free speech from someone who presents himself as a libertarian and a principled writer. Emil van der Poorten commented: “In the interests of the sanity of the rest of us, Sanjana and Uvindu would be well advised to leave the O’Learys/Colmans out of the columns of the publications they have responsibility for.” Surely such a man could not be asking for a fellow writer’s work to be banned! When CT decided to ban Dr Vickramabahu, van der Poorten took a principled stand: “I have serious concerns about something that smacks of censorship and throwing the baby out with the bathwater here.” Continue reading

1 Comment

Filed under accountability, citizen journalism, cultural transmission, discrimination, disparagement, life stories, politIcal discourse, self-reflexivity, slanted reportage, sri lankan society, tolerance

Moral immaturity befuddles the humanitarians on the asylum-seeker issue

Greg Sheridan, in The Australian, 1 August 2013, where the title reads Bleeding hearts ignore the complexity of the asylum-seeker issues”

greg sheridan AT q AND aWHAT are the real ethics of boatpeople policies? Malcolm Fraser, Phillip Adams, Dennis Altman, John Hewson, Christine Milne and the entire refugee lobby have described the policies of both Kevin Rudd and Tony Abbott in ways that make it clear they are to be regarded as immoral, unethical, bigoted, unfair, demonising and so on. Even the Catholic bishops, normally a sober body of men, have called for an end to mandatory detention of people who arrive illegally by boat. As it happens I knew both Rudd and Abbott for many years before they went into politics. Both are ruthless politicians, but both also are conscientious Christians and neither, I am certain, would ever pursue policies in relation to the disposition of human beings that they believed to be unconscionably wrong. Continue reading

2 Comments

Filed under asylum-seekers, Australian culture, australian media, cultural transmission, discrimination, disparagement, economic processes, ethnicity, fundamentalism, historical interpretation, Indian Ocean politics, legal issues, life stories, politIcal discourse, power politics, racist thinking, Sinhala-Tamil Relations, slanted reportage, sri lankan society, tolerance, truth as casualty of war, world events & processes

The psychoanalysis of racism, nationalism and revolution

Richard Koenigsberg

KoenigsbergEXTRACTS as introduction….

Faith in the NationThe idea of the nation is a fundamental “assumption” that defines the manner in which modern man perceives, and experiences, social reality. Just as people in earlier historical periods possessed an absolute faith in the reality of God, so do people in contemporary cultures possess an absolute faith in the reality of the nation.

In a democratic culture, people differ regarding the stance taken in relation to the nation: the country may be “loved” or hated; perceived to be “healthy” or sick; “strong” or weak. But whatever stance is adopted, people are united by their absolute faith in the reality of this entity, and their belief that this entity constitutes a fundamental determinant of the nature, and of the quality, of their daily lives. Continue reading

Leave a comment

Filed under atrocities, Fascism, Hitler, life stories, nationalism, performance, politIcal discourse, power politics, propaganda, unusual people, violence of language, zealotry

A “congress of baboons”

One must get ones’ collective nouns and metaphors right!

parliament of baboons 33  parliament of baboons 22

parliament of baboons 11

SL PARL in session 11 Continue reading

2 Comments

Filed under accountability, cultural transmission, democratic measures, disparagement, fundamentalism, governance, life stories, performance, political demonstrations, politIcal discourse, power politics, welfare & philanthophy, world affairs

Island-hopping: from Lanka to Cocos to Christmas and thence to Manus perhaps

sl -asylum-seekers-colin murty Sri  Lankan asylum-seekers arrive at Christmas Island airport after being flown from the Cocos  Islands yesterday. Picture: Colin Murty  Source: The Australian… ALSO SEE Rowan Callick: “Airlift to Manus swings into action,”  http://www.theaustralian.com.au/national-affairs/election-2013/airlift-to-extend-manus-swings-into-action/story-fn9qr68y-1226687190919 AND

Kamal Wickremasinghe, “Bogus refugees are making waves in Australia,” Daily News, 29 July 2013, http://www.dailynews.lk/?q=features/bogus-refugees-are-making-waves-australia

Leave a comment

Filed under asylum-seekers, australian media, authoritarian regimes, life stories, people smugglers, politIcal discourse, pulling the leg, Sinhala-Tamil Relations, slanted reportage, sri lankan society, Tamil migration, tolerance, truth as casualty of war, unusual people, world events & processes

Profound sorrow. Selvamalar and Balamanokaran lose their son at sea off Java

Paul Toohey & Ashley Mullany, in The Advertiser, Sunday, 28 July with title as I just want my baby boy back”

About 1000 asylum seekers have died trying to get to Australia illegally by boat since the Labor Government was elected. The Sunday Times was on the scene in the immediate aftermath of the latest boat tragedy this week and, in a common but rarely captured story, can tell why one woman took an extraordinary risk to reach her husband in Perth and suffered the most painful loss of all. Special report by Paul Toohey in Java and Ashlee Mullany in Perth.

SelvakumarSHE was sold a cruel lie by the people smugglers. He will never meet his son. She was told she would travel on a luxury ocean liner from Indonesia to Australia. They showed her photos of the ship that would transport her, her beautiful son and her brother to their new life in Australia. It was a superb vessel, with three storeys of cabins. “I believed them,” she said. Continue reading

Leave a comment

Filed under asylum-seekers, Australian culture, australian media, historical interpretation, immigration, life stories, people smugglers, politIcal discourse, slanted reportage, sri lankan society, Tamil migration, tamil refugees, women in ethnic conflcits, world events & processes

Ahoy! A Ship! A Ship! The BOATS in the asylum-seeker brouhaha

Michael Roberts[i]

Amidst all the convenient statistics bandied around by all political parties, including “victim agencies”, there is an absence of a critical social science breakdown.[ii] Since boats depart from four main regions one requires a statistical breakdown that separate source of origin and proportion that floundered according to source of origin for the following periods, say (I) 2001-07; (II) 2008-2012;  (III) 2013 thus far.

A = Indonesia

B = Sri Lanka

C = India

D= Malaysia

THE QUESTION is

  1. How many made it safely from each source?
  2. How many (a) floundered and from within this lot (b) how many were deliberately sabotaged? Continue reading

3 Comments

Filed under accountability, asylum-seekers, Australian culture, australian media, cultural transmission, disparagement, historical interpretation, immigration, life stories, politIcal discourse, racist thinking, Tamil migration

A grieving Tamil couple … and credulous Australians

Michael Roberts

The headline picture in The Australian was — and remains — gut-wrenching, harrowing. It is a tale of searing suffering: a  young Sri Lankan Tamil couple have just lost their ten-month old infant after a boat with asylum seekers that had set off from Java sank off shore. Take Peter Alford’s story filed from Java yesterday.
  • TAMIL COUPLE
    Hard line unheard or unheeded by asylum-seekers

    The Australian·20 hours ago   

    A baby boy and a 10-year-old girl are believed to be among the dead after an asylum boat sank off Java. THE asylum-seekers from the latest sinking tragedy….

The two are Antony Jayaseelan and Rose Anu Resana, Tamils of Catholic background. They were among the 204 people on board on a boat that had left Cidaun in Java on Tuesday and then floundered in the sea, leaving 44 missing and 4 confirmed dead. It would seem that these asylum-seekers were not aware of the new Rudd-government’s hardline policy. Said Jayaseelan: “We didn’t know but even if we did know we could not stay in Sri Lanka.” Continue reading

2 Comments

Filed under asylum-seekers, Australian culture, australian media, cultural transmission, economic processes, ethnicity, historical interpretation, immigration, Indian Ocean politics, island economy, legal issues, life stories, people smugglers, politIcal discourse, Sinhala-Tamil Relations, slanted reportage, sri lankan society, Tamil migration, truth as casualty of war

Achtung! Achtung! The Asian Boats! Let’s defend Australia’s fatal shore

David Crowe & Rowan Callick, in The Australian, 25 July 2013, where the title reads Kevin Rudd’s PNG splurge to match the rush of boats”

LABOR has vowed to build an “extraordinary capacity” to deal with the latest wave of asylum-seekers as it tries to stare down people-smugglers by ensuring it has room for thousands of new arrivals, despite the mounting cost to the budget. Defence staff and civil contractors were clearing part of Manus Island yesterday to take the influx as another four boats were intercepted, breaching the official capacity of the island’s detention centre. A giant Antonov cargo aircraft will this weekend head to Papua New Guinea to supply the “rapid expansion” of tents and marquees around the existing centre as the government inspects sites on other parts of the island to set up more camps. Continue reading

Leave a comment

Filed under asylum-seekers, Australian culture, australian media, fundamentalism, historical interpretation, immigration, life stories, nationalism, politIcal discourse, power politics, slanted reportage, tolerance, trauma, truth as casualty of war, world events & processes

Black July 83: Two Statements in The NATION

I: Editorial: “Black July 83 never again,” 21 July 2013

Remember Black July ’83’ is a print-ad campaign designed by the advertising agency JWT for the Centre for Policy Alternatives (CPA), a controversial NGO that has come in for a lot of flak from multiple quarters on grounds of financial dishonesty and aiding and abetting separatism.  ‘Never to repeat’ is the payoff line.  The campaign is to be launched shortly, The Nation learns. ‘Black July’ is remembered and remembered differently and for varying purposes by those who remember.  Whatever these differences may be there is commonality in agreement on one thing: it should never happen again.

14b--By midnight Borella town became a place where devils reign. A Scene in Borella–Pic from Victor Ivan

There’s nothing to say that ‘Black July’ will not recur.  There’s nothing to say that it must.  On the other hand, if it is not to happen again, it is important to remember what happened.  It is important to acknowledge that it inflicted a deep wound on the nation, the people who make it, their collective and individual memory; a wound that has bled into many other lacerations.  This has been a common view expressed by many across the political spectrum. Continue reading

2 Comments

Filed under accountability, JVP, life stories, LTTE, nationalism, political demonstrations, politIcal discourse, power politics, racist thinking, riots and pogroms, self-reflexivity, Sinhala-Tamil Relations, sri lankan society, Tamil civilians, terrorism, trauma, violence of language