Shenali D Waduge, reproducing here an old article in Lankaweb from 22 December 2013 which I had not seen even though I had interacted closely with Murali in Colombo in May-June 2009 (as well as subsequently) and been commissioned to write pieces for Frontline; while also been privileged to chat with Kanchan Prasad in mid-2010 after Murali introduced me to her, after which I gained access to her invaluable snaps of the Nandikadal war zone. These I placed in a special site, viz. http://www.flickr.com/photos/thuppahi/sets/72157626797805167/ et seq.
Waduge’s article is entitled “Sri Lanka’s War had Witnesses : Indian Journalist B. Murali Reddy”. In the reproduction below, the highlighting in red [as distinct from black] is my imposition as Editor, Thuppahi. Also see my SPECIAL NOTE at the end
Firstly Sri Lanka’s war did have witnesses. The witnesses were however NOT – Gordon Weiss, Francis Harrison, Channel 4, the Darusman Panel, Charles Petrie and a whole list of others who have promoted themselves as witnesses when they are not because they were never inside the war zone. They were only passing between themselves a version they have contrived that fits well within a different agenda that has nothing to do with what they claim it is. Questioning their credibility further is their sources – who happen to all be pro-LTTE. However, there was a witness throughout. He was foreign and his name is B. Muralidhar Reddy, an Indian journalist working for The Hindu/Frontline and his account “Final Hours – An eyewitness account of the last 70 hours of Eelam War IV’ gives a real eyewitness account of what he himself saw. http://www.frontline.in/static/html/fl2612/stories/20090619261200900.htm
The accusations and allegations against Sri Lanka have been pouring in and much of these allegations had been prepared in advance even before the war ended. What cannot escape anyone’s attention is that the Indian journalist Murali Reddy was in fact the only foreign journalist who was virtually in the thick of things and remains the best witness who was able to see how the Sri Lankan military was carrying out its military operation as well as being aware of the status of civilians and their safety. None of Murali Reddy’s breaking news sent which he admits was never wetted nor was he denied internet access carried even a word or subtly implied that the armed forces were deliberately compromising the safety of the civilians. Murali Reddy’s accounts become both significant and important in the light of those who had never been anywhere near the war zone but depicting supposed atrocities as taking place as if they had witnessed these themselves when none of these collaborate with Murali Reddy’s witness account.
Accusation: No Foreign Journalists allowed into War Zone
Accusation Falsified: Murali Reddy was a journalist and part of a group of journalists from The Hindu/Frontline and All India Radio/Doordarshan. These were the ONLY foreign print/electronic media allowed access. The Indian journalists were attached to the 58 Division of the Sri Lanka Army headed by Brig. Shavendra Silva.
Accusation: Sri Lanka Government restricted coverage from war zone
Accusation Falsified: The Indian journalists confirm that there was no conditions spelled out on the coverage from the war zone. ‘we were allowed unfettered and unhindered movement upto about 400metres from the zone, where pitched battles were fought between the military and the remaining cadre and leaders of the LTTE.’….’We also got an occasional peep, under the watchful eyes of senior officers, into the operations room at the headquarters of 58 Division, where 24/7 imagery of the war zone, obtained by Unmanned Aerial Vehicles, were beamed on small and large television screens. In addition, the military conducted tours, often 300 to 400 metres away from the last battle zone, once the ground situation was under the firm control of the forces.” Gordon Weiss, Francis Harrison or C4 never had NO such access. What they ended up doing to obtain for themselves world fame was to make 2+2 into 40,000 and more.
‘Most important was the fact that we had interference-free access to the Internet, including TamilNet, the website perceived to be pro-LTTE and based somewhere in Europe. Within the constraints of Internet time available, and not-unexpected problems of connectivity and speed in a war zone, there was just enough time to read and absorb the reports on the website before sending news dispatches to our headquarters. No questions were asked.’ In stark contrast all embedded journalists of the Gulf Wars had every item written security reviewed.
This also indicates that if the journalists were having access to the internet they also would have been aware of the allegations of civilian casualties being made and they would have themselves been best placed to confirm the allegations or kept a watchful eye.
Nothing of Murali Reddy’s ‘Last Hours” remotely suggests any foul play in the last 70 hours of the Eelam War IV starting out at 3p.m. on May 16 and stops at 12.30 p.m. on May 19th 2009.
According to Murali the last batch of Tamil civilians who fled LTTE-occupied zone were 80,000. What is also interesting is that Murali’s discussions with this last batch showed that the LTTE by 10th May had realized they approached their Waterloo and that there was no purpose in holding on to the civilians. Murali however accepts that the LTTE were not clear on how the LTTE wanted to end the war. They could have kept the civilians, used them as human shields, or killed themselves along with the civilians but that would depend on how much of ammunition they had left. What LTTE did decide by 11th May was to desert the sentry points, dismantle the defense lines and destroy whatever they could.
Accusation: Army fired indiscriminately at civilians during the last phase
- If according to Murali the LTTE by 11th May had decided to destroy the sentry points and dismantle the defense lines the fact that the civilians were allowed to move out of LTTE stranglehold started on May 12/13.
- The most important piece of information comes when Reddy says ‘by the night of May 15 there was no civilians left in 1.5sq.km area the Tigers were boxed into’. It was because there were no civilians that the International Committee of the Red Cross who were the only other outfit present inside the war zone decided to suspend humanitarian operations.
- This announcement was made because it was clear that all civilians had been moved out of the war zone to safety and only the army and the LTTE were left to fight out the final battle. This reveals that there was absolutely no civilian after 16th May to 19th May inside the war zone. How could then 40,000 or even 125,000 have been killed?
- The last of the civilians were members of LTTE families was seen in the detention of Sea Tiger Chief Soosai’s family by the Navy on 15/16 May. On 16th May close to 50,000 escaped to safety. It must also be mentioned that Prabakaran’s parents too would have accompanied the civilians for they were eventually found on 27 May by the military in a camp.
- Reddy also says that Soosai’s wife had confirmed that Prabakaran was inside the war zone along with his son Charles Anthony, Pottu Amman and Soosai.
- Reddy’s quote of Tamilnet “An uncounted number of dead bodies, between 2,000 and 3,000, are lying all over the place in civilian congested area and the civilians are all struck by a heavy stench of dead bodies.” deciphered in essence must mean that 2000-3000 were not ‘civilians’ but LTTE cadres – either they had been shot by the Sri Lankan army or the LTTE had shot their own cadres those who perhaps would have been injured and unable to move with the others. We saw how LTTE killed their own cadres by putting their own men/women into a bus and setting it on fire.
- It was also on 16th May that President Rajapakse had declared at the G11 Summit in Jordan that the LTTE was defeated and that he was returning to Sri Lanka ‘as a leader of a nation that vanquished terrorism’.
- It was at this same G11 summit that President Rajapakse had informed ICRC that the Sri Lankan Government was ready to accept the surrender of the LTTE it is was unconditional. The LTTE were however not ready to surrender to the military.
- President Rajapakse at the G11 Summit goes on to say “History has taught us that solutions externally prescribed, with little understanding of the complexity of the problem on the ground, are prone to failure. My government is, therefore, firmly committed to seeking a home-grown solution acceptable to all communities living in Sri Lanka,”
Thus according to Reddy the end of the LTTE inside the war zone without Tamil civilians began on May 16 with the clearing of the coastline.
That the coastline was cleared and under the Sri Lankan army reveals that the LTTE was now cornered inland. This led to an intense battle on 17 May as early as 5a.m. Murali Reddy himself say’ the tigers waged a hopeless battle in a bid to prolong the inevitable, if not exactly to save the LTTE top brass’. Reddy calls it a 22 hour battle and says that by 18th May the army chief was not able to confirm the death of Prabakaran.
Alongside the 18 LTTE leaders a further 250 bodies were also found. There is also the telephone message by Nadesan and Pulithevan to their contacts in Europe on 18 May that around 1000 wounded cadres, civil officials of LTTE and civilians remains inside the safety zone. That there was no mention of any 40,000 civilians inside the zone is another proof that this number is nothing but a concocted lie.
It was only on 19th May in the afternoon that the troops had recovered the bodies of Prabakaran and Soosai though Tamilnet quoted KP as saying that Prabakaran was ‘alive and well’.
Reddy also quotes Marie Colvin (The Sunday Times, London) who had in the 24 May internet edition written that Nadesan had contacted her on 17 May to ask her to broker a surrender for himself and Pulithevan. What was clearly implied was that the LTTE leaders themselves were breaking ranks with the LTTE leadership.
Thus, Murali Reddy’s Last Hours covers from 3p.m. 16h May to 12:30p.m. 19th May 2009.
|10th May||LTTE realizing their fate|
|11th May||LTTE destroying their belongings|
|12/13th May||LTTE allows civilians to leave|
|15th May||Important events .· No civilians in 1.5sq.km that LTTE was boxed into
· ICRC suspends operations because there are no civilians.
· No civilians from 16th to 19th May – How could there have been 40,000 to 125,000 civilians?
|16th May||· 50,000 civilians escape (could this be the figure that is being alleged as dead?)· President Rajapakse informs ICRC that his Government will offer an unconditional surrender which LTTE refuse.|
|17-18th May||· Pitch battle between LTTE and Sri Lankan Army|
|19th May||· Announcement of Prabakaran’s death|
The witness accounts by Murali Reddy given as hot news from the war zone itself shows a different version to what is today being used against Sri Lanka so much so that the UN is claiming it had failed when the UN should ideally accept that it failed 20million Sri Lankan citizens by allowing LTTE to thrive for 30 years.
The UN Office in Colombo estimated that approximately 7000 civilians were killed in the final stages of the war. The 7000 or something figure was jacked up to 40,000 by Gordon Weiss after landing in Australia. He changed this number to 10,000 at his book launch and disowned responsibility for the change of numbers attributing it to the printers!
There are others joining in the guestimates – Charles Petrie says 70,000 in his report
The number of dead quoted by the UN country team in Sri Lanka was 7721 people while the Tamilnet the LTTE propaganda wing reported a total of 7398 deaths.
The comprehensive survey by the Government in the Northern region placed the number of dead and missing during the final phase at 7400 dead and 2600 missing. The 7400 dead included LTTE fighters killed in combat. Of the 2600 missing, 1600 had been with the LTTE whereas only 438 had disappeared in areas under military control.
The American Association for the Advancement of Science could only report 960 burials and we again come back to the golden question where are the 40,000 dead bodies?
We just have to ask how these people counted the dead bodies or what benchmark they are using to calculate the numbers given that in a Tamil population of 2.2million of which 1mllion Tamils are now living overseas.
Even so, the dead must have names – what are their names? The dead must have relatives – where are the relatives? How come none of these 40,000 relatives submitted their names to the Darusman Panel? To date we do not know who these 40,000 or 125,000 are and it is time we call the bluff and demand to know the exact names of the dead without throwing barren accusations.
As for Reddy, he is an Indian journalist and has no requirement to speak on behalf of either the LTTE or the Sri Lankan army. His accounts of the Last Hours have been as he had witnessed them and in taking his version against the allegations been made – we can only conclude that someone is lying and it appears the liars are those who were never witness but are claiming to have seen 40,000 dead bodies but they don’t know who they are and 4 years on they still cant find their names or relatives.
*** END ****
It is probably very rare for reporters to gain access to the forward lines of fighting in those situations where battle lines are clear-cut. It would also be erroneous to think that the Indian duo would be able to see what was going on within every sector of the Karayanmullivaikkal & Vellamullavaikkal arenas where the action occurred on the last 4-5 days of the battles. So provisos must be attached to the assessment by Waduge from an amateur position of an urbanite. Nor does their witness engage the immediate aftermath of the SL Army’s success from the 19th May to say the 30th May when the GSL forces had to deal with the surviving LTTE fighters and key backroom personnel. However, their reportage and Kanchan’s pictures give us invaluable footage on the scenario of battle as well as indicative pictures of the resilient strength of some civilian survivors. One set of photos also disprove LTTE and foreign reportage that asserted confidently that one of the makeshift hospitals had been bombarded and hit — for Murali and Kanchan headed for those specific coordinates on one of their visits — see http://www.flickr.com/photos/thuppahi/sets/72157626797848747/ The LTTE propaganda machinery cleverly used Tamil NGO functionaries and the medical personnel engaged in their vital activities to present pictures of carnage among the people that were kept hostage as so many sandbags in a defensive formation that was also a ploy to attract foreign intervention. This picture was bought hook, line and sinker by the Western media as well as the human rights agencies in the island and abroad. In contrast to Reuters even Ravi Nessman of the Associated Press and Gordon Weiss of the UN Media Office accepted this mantra. As late as 9th/10th May they insisted that this was a war without witnesses with no regard for the live UAV footage shown to key media personnel on the 20th April and the reports appearing in Frontline, the Hindu and Reuters outlets. … Michael Roberts
ALSO SEE – KANCHAN & MURALI …. plus Roberts findings
- Tiger Dead & Vestments = http://www.flickr.com/photos/thuppahi/sets/72157626922473698/
- Tent City in the Last Redoubt of the LTTE = http://www.flickr.com/photos/thuppahi/sets/72157626826325831/with/5828587480/
- Indian Reporter Pics at NFZ-14-to-18 May 2009 = http://www.flickr.com/photos/thuppahi/sets/72157626797805167/
- Mullivaikkal Hospital in NFZ Last Redoubt = http://www.flickr.com/photos/thuppahi/sets/72157626797848747/
- TIMES Aerial Images, NFZ Last Redoubt, 23 May 2009 = http://www.flickr.com/photos/thuppahi/sets/72157626922360092/
- Final Battle, NFZ Last Redoubt, 13-19 May 2009= http://www.flickr.com/photos/thuppahi/sets/72157626921596968/
- The Maakkal Padai or Peoples Militia as Arm of the LTTE during Eelam War IV = http://www.flickr.com/photos/thuppahi/sets/72157627005320170/
AND OTHER AUTHORS
Hull, C. Bryson & Ranga Sirilal 2009 “Sri Lankan War in Endgame, 100,000 escape rebel zone,” 23 April 2009, http://www.reuters.com/article/us-srilanka-war-idUSTRE53J0IZ20090422
Gray, David 2009 “A Day at the Front Line in Sri Lanka (Photographer’s Blog),” 27 April 2009, http://blogs.reuters.com/photographers-blog/2009/04/27/a-day-at-the-front-line-in-sri-lanka/
Hull, C. Bryson & Ranga Sirilal 2009 “Sri Lanka’s long war in bloody final climax,” 17 May 2009, http://mg.co.za/article/2009-05-17-sri-lankas-long-war-in-bloody-final-climax
Hull, C Bryson & R. Srilal 2009 “Last phase of Sri Lanka war killed 6,200 troops: government,” 22 May 2009, http://www.reuters.com/article/us-srilanka-war-idUSTRE54L0YW20090522
- IDAG [i.e. Citizen Silva] 2013 “The Numbers Game: Politics of Retributive Justice,” http://www.scribd.com/doc/132499266/The-Numbers-Game-Politics-of-Retributive-Justice OR http://www.satp.org/satporgtp/countries/shrilanka/document/TheNG.pd
- [Nessman] 2014 “The War in Sri Lanka: Ravi Nessman’s Slanted Story for USA on the Tavis Smiley Show, 18 February 2009,” 31 January 2014, https://thuppahis.com/2014/01/31/the-war-in-sri-lanka-ravi-nessmans-slanted-story-for-usa-on-the-tavis-smiley-show-18-february-200/
- Padraig Colman 2011 “Evaluating the ‘Churnalism’ from Channel 4 and the Moon Panel,” 17 August 2011, http:// thuppahi.wordpress.com/2011/08/17/a-credible-evaluation-of-%e2%80%9cchurnalism%e2%80%9d-from-channel-4-and-themoon-panel/.
- Reddy, B. Muralidhar 2009c “End Game,” Frontline 26/10, 9-22 May 2009
- Reddy, B. Muralidhar 2009 “An Escape from Hellhole,” http://www.
- Reddy, Muralidhar 2009g “Multiple Displacements, Total Loss of Identity,” The Hindu, 27 May 2009, http://www.hindu.com/2009/05/27/stories/2009052755811500.htm
- Reddy, Muralidhar 2009e “Final Assault. A first-hand account of the war and the civilians’ plight as Eelam War almost comes to a close,” Frontline, 26/11, May 23-June 5, 2009, http://www.frontline.in/navigation/?type=static&page=archive.
- Reddy, Muralidhar 2009f “Final Hours. An eye-witness account of the last 70 hours of Eelam War IV,” Frontline, 26/12, 6-19 June 2009, http://www.frontline.in/static/html/fl2612/stories/20090619261200900.htm
- Reddy, Muralidhar 2013 A review of Frances Harrison’s Still Counting the Dead …, The Hindu of February 19, 2013
- Roberts, M. 2009 “Realities of War,” Frontline, May 9-22, http://www.frontline.in/static/html/fl2610/stories/20090522261001600.htm
- Roberts, M. 2014 “Generating Calamity, 2008-2014: An Overview of Tamil Nationalist Operations and Their Marvels,” 10 April 2014, http://groundviews.org/2014/04/10/generating-calamity-2008-2014-an-overview-of-tamil-nationalist-operations-and-their-marvels/
- Roberts, M. 2014- “The War in Sri Lanka: Ravi Nessman’s Slanted Story for USA on the Tavis Smiley Show, 18 February 2009,” 31 January 2014, https://thuppahis.com/2014/01/31/the-war-in-sri-lanka-ravi-nessmans-slanted-story-for-usa-on-the-tavis-smiley-show-18-february-200/
- Roberts, M. 2014 “Dedicated Medical Work Amidst the Heat of War, Death and Propaganda: In the Vanni Pocket, 2009,” https://thuppahis.com/ 2012/04/12/blackmail-during-the-endgame-in-eelam-war-iv/
- Roberts, M. 2015 “The Realities of Eelam War IV,” 27 October 2015, https://thuppahis.com/2015/10/27/the-realities-of-eelam-war-iv/
- Roberts, M. 2015 “Down to Earth: The Hard Truths of Eelam War IV,” 29 October 2015, http://www.sinhalanet.net/down-to-earth-the-hard-truths-of-eelam-war-iv
- Roberts, M. 2016 “Reuters in Word and Image: Depicting the Penetration of the LTTE’s Last Redoubt, 19-22 April 2009,” 19 March 2016, https://thuppahis.com/2016/03/19/reuters-in-word-and-image-depicting-the-penetration-of-the-lttes-last-redoubt-19-22-april-2009/
- Roberts, M. 2016 “A Puzzle: When Weiss, Amnesty International and Aussie Greens Lie,” 16 June 2016, https://thuppahis.com/2016/06/16/a-puzzle-when-weiss-amnesty-international-and-aussie-greens-lie/
- Thangavelu, Velupillai 2013 “LTTE Cadres Who Surrendered To The Army: Where Are They?” Colombo Telegraph, 18 August 2013, http://www.colombotelegraph.com/index.php/ltte-cadres-who-surrendered-to-the-army-where-are-they/