Rajasingham Narendran, presenting a blog comment within http://transcurrents.com/news-views/archives/6285 which is an article by Michael Roberts, “The Tamil Death Toll in Early 2009: A Misleading Count by Rohan Gunaratna,” 23 November 2011.**
As addendum to Prof. Michael Roberts presentation, I hereby present briefly what I witnessed with regard to the bodies of my family members and others killed by the IPKF on day 10 of their murders: My mother: 68 year old at the time of her killing. Slim build. Had been attacked by animals and crows and was in an advanced state of decay. My brother: 38 year old at the time of his death. neither obese or thin. Body intact though bloated. The gardener: Age approx. 60 years. Obese. All flesh had fallen off and the skeleton was clearly visible .A neighbour’s Watchman: Age approx. 60 years. medium build. Only thigh bones-femurs and the skull remained. The rest of the body had been consumed or carried away by animals.
The incident happened in the month of October, when the climate is relatively mild. Maggots and flies were swarming around the bodies.
These observations imply that in the Vanni in the period around April’ 2009, when the summer is at its hottest, bodies would have decomposed faster. the older and the obese bodies would have deteriorated faster than those of the younger and thinner ones. Being largely an area that is in proximity to jungles and teaming with wild animals of all sorts, most of the dead would have been partially or totally consumed by wild animals. Flies and maggots would have accelerated the decay.
These observations indicate that the number of dead will always be unknown and subject to speculation. It will also be difficult to statistically enumerate the dead through surveys, because many were smuggled out of camps, many left by boats and many survivors simply do not know whether their relatives are living or dead. Many who had to abandon the week and infirm yet are unsure as to what happened to them.
I met a grandmother who had a 5-6 month old grandchild on her lap in the Gamini Vidyalaya transit camp (Vavuniya). She said that both her daughter and son-in law were dead and was unaware of what happened to her other relatives. There were many with similar tragic tales. One can only have a ‘feel’ for the possible numbers dead and this feel has to be translated into probable numbers. It can be approximate or likely, but can never be accurate.
**Editorial Note: Narendran was addressing (1) some Tamil nationalist bloggers who seemed to think that a census would easily settle the issue of the death toll and (2) one “Uthayakumar” (23 Nov. 2011) who purported to be living a “few kilometers from [the] Vanni boundary” and asserted that only 150 civilians died!
Pingback: Update On Ibadan Horror: Arrests Made, Female Victim Speaks - Nollywood Magazine | Nollywood Magazine
Pingback: Fashioning a Spectre of Disaster with Aid from Humanitarian Agencies: Tamil Marvels | Thuppahi's Blog
Pingback: From MICHAEL ROBERTS, Anthropology, Adelaide University to SANDRA BEIDAS of OHCHR |
Pingback: The war in Sri Lanka and propaganda debates: An analysis for the OHCHR in Geneva | Lankan Expats
Pingback: The War in Sri Lanka and Propaganda Debates | Thuppahi's Blog
Pingback: A Drama in Four Acts: Dishonest Reportage by Amnesty International and Aussie Journalists remains Unmasked | Thuppahi's Blog
Pingback: unmasked Amnesty Internatonal and Aussie journalists | TAMIL TIGER ACTIVITIES
Pingback: The Realities of Eelam War IV | Thuppahi's Blog
Pingback: Lilliputs in a World of Giants: Marga and CHA bat for Lanka in the Propaganda War, 2009-14 | Thuppahi's Blog
Pingback: Sturdy Advocacy: Marga’s Questioning of the UNPoE Assassination Job | Thuppahi's Blog
Pingback: David Cameron’s Double Standards in Stark Nudity | Thuppahi's Blog
Pingback: Lavish Five-Star picture of Sri Lanka as Travel Destination in traveller.com | Thuppahi's Blog
Pingback: No Groundwork, No Critical Thinking. A Dilettante Thinker’s Foray into Sri Lanka | Thuppahi's Blog
Pingback: Saving Talaivar Pirapāharan | Thuppahi's Blog
Pingback: The MISSING in the War Years: A Cumulative Bibliography as Aide | Thuppahi's Blog
Pingback: Meeting Ex-Tigers and Addressing the Issue of Rehabilitation | Thuppahi's Blog
Pingback: Groundviews on Disappearances and the OMP | Thuppahi's Blog
Pingback: The Missing in Lanka: An Old Bibliography … Further Supplemented | Thuppahi's Blog
Pingback: Gems and Nuggets within the Commentary on SINHALA MINDSET: Reflections | Thuppahi's Blog
Pingback: Disappearances and Torture in Lanka, 2009-16: A Bibliography | Thuppahi's Blog
Pingback: Targeting Lanka by Playing Ball with Tamil Extremism: 2008-14 | Thuppahi's Blog
Pingback: The War Dead in Sri Lanka: Deceit and Ignorance Rule the Air Waves | Thuppahi's Blog
Pingback: A Down-to-Earth Review of E-War IV and Its Literature | Thuppahi's Blog
Pingback: The Death Toll in 2009: Deceit and Myopia, International and Lankan | Thuppahi's Blog
Pingback: Solheim and Sri Lanka: Q and A Today | Thuppahi's Blog
Pingback: Vale. In Memoriam. Dr. Rajasingham Narendran | Thuppahi's Blog
Pingback: Reconciliation via Cricket and Charity? The Political Ground is a Waterlogged Minefield | Thuppahi's Blog
Pingback: Baron Naseby and the Merry-Go-Round on Sri Lankan Politics, 1975-2017 | Thuppahi's Blog
Pingback: Revelations in Britain: Lord Naseby undermines the received ‘Wisdom’ on Civilian Deaths | Thuppahi's Blog
Pingback: Revelations in Britain: Lord Naseby undermines the received ‘Wisdom’ on Civilian Deaths
Pingback: Infantry Warfare and the Final Phase of Eelam War IV: Where Laymen Blunder into Infantile Assessments | Thuppahi's Blog
Pingback: Accusers Accused — by Lord Michael Naseby | Thuppahi's Blog
Pingback: Missing Persons: Q and A with Mirak Raheem | Thuppahi's Blog
Pingback: The Western World’s Cumulous Clouds of Deception: Blanketing the Sharp Realities of Eelam War IV | Thuppahi's Blog
Pingback: Tamils pay Homage to Dead Tigers on 27th November: Channel 4 You Tube on Deep Scars of the Wars | Thuppahi's Blog
Pingback: Prejudiced and Infantile Readings of Sri Lanka at Chatham House in 2019 | Thuppahi's Blog
Pingback: Arrogance, Ignorance, Deceit: The Many Faces of Taylor Dibbert | Thuppahi's Blog
Pingback: Sri Lanka, 2010-2019: Positive Changes but Sinhala Buddhist Dominance still prevails — Alan Keenan | Thuppahi's Blog
Pingback: The Many Strands of Extremism TODAY: Salafi, Racial, Chauvinist and HR | Thuppahi's Blog
Pingback: Dr Narendran Rajasingham: A Tamil Sri Lankan Indomitable and Sincere | Thuppahi's Blog
Pingback: The Gash Files and Beyond | Thuppahi's Blog
Pingback: Narendran’s Critical Dissection of Mahinda Rajapaksa’s Victory Day Speech on 18th May 2009 | Thuppahi's Blog
Pingback: Insights for Today: A Reuter’s Report from the Eelam War Front in Late February 2009 | Thuppahi's Blog
Pingback: Ludicrous Verdicts in Powerful Quarters Still Asserted TODAY: Death Toll in Eelam War IV Magnified Manifold | Thuppahi's Blog
Pingback: The HR Lobby in UK: Deskbound and Devious | Thuppahi's Blog
Pingback: The HR Lobby in UK: Deskbound and Devious – NewsHub Sri Lanka
Pingback: Chandraprema to beard the UNHCR Den in Geneva | Thuppahi's Blog
Pingback: Justin Trudeau Rapped on Knuckles for Statement on Victims of Eelam War | Thuppahi's Blog
Pingback: Western Real-Politic at UNHRC Sesions in Geneva, 2021 | Thuppahi's Blog