Site icon Thuppahi's Blog

Debating the Value of Tangential Historical Forays

Michael Roberts

 A FEW DAYS BACK, on 28th November 2023, I circulated this item among Lankan aficianado…. [ Let me add, here, that I was prompted to do this by the burgeoning world debate on the Palestinian-Israeli War that has been raging since August]. ………………………………………………………………….. https://thuppahis.com/2014/11/18/cartographic-photographic and -illustrations-in-support-of-the-memorandum-analysing-the-war-in-sri-lanka-and-propaganda

ROHANTHA GUNARATNA in Canada responded in critical fashion. …. So I circulated his Memo to some personnel  with this NOTE: “I encourage responses [to his Memo] from interested personnel – here, quite deliberately, reaching out beyond Lankans to Indians and Brits familiar with the Lankan scene in that period past.”

 

EMAIL NOTE from ROHANTHA GUNARATNA, 28 November 2023

Hi Mr Michael Roberts ,

I cannot see the point in this regurgitation you seem to be hell bent on .

This stupid war finished over 12 years ago and in that span of time the British were reconciled with The denizens of Dresden after having flattened it to rubble just a few months before the ending of WW 2 killing many civilians and children far far too many than the IDF is executing in Gaza.

Very much like what the “ treaty of Versailles “ did unintentionally was to fan the flames of phoenixes by creating a monster called Nazism a form of fascism with a disdain for liberal democracy.

Let me highlight the many tentacles of bonding that was taken as absolute norm in my family circles before the rise of Prabakaram

My fathers brother Richard ( also a Royalist ) married from the Tamil community, siring a Dr Motilal now in the US

My first cousin Hema de Zoysa (also a Royalist) , a Director of the World Bank married from the Tamil community. His grandson died in the Easter bombing at the Cinnamon Grand whilst on holiday from Washington.

My uncle Sir Lalitha Rajapakse , the very first Minister of Justice under DS with the unique accolade of being one of the youngest PHD in Law in the UK had a sister in law married to a Tamil MP of Batticalloa.

Indrajit’s father in law married a lady ( Tara’s mother ) also from the  T C.

My mothers flower girl was Dr a Ratnesan’s mother .

Both of my eldest sisters weddings were attested by Professor Mylvaganam.

Skanda’s sister is married to the son of Bunty de Zoysa one time Attorney General .

My best friends at Royal were Ratna Sivaratnam, Indy Perayerawar, the Selvaratnam boys, and very many others.

My niece Rangita de Silva de Alwis a present Law Professor at Penn University with a Masters and a PHD at Harvard flew in to give an oration for the requiem memorium of a famed Tamil Harvard law graduate Dr Nilan……who was assassinated by the Tigers.

For Pete’s sake man do not fan the flames of hatred , have empathy and the compassion to douse the flames and let all bond and live life without enmity.

The latest vote in the Canadian parliament to have a law passed for a Tamil subjugation week’s remembrance is a unnecessary adding fuel to a dying fire simply because having lived in England for nearly 60 years see visibly a sense of togetherness developing by solid “ give and take bonhomie.

Think about what I have spelled out please without rancour and imbibe friendship like you and I seem to link through Ismeth and Dilini ( my friend from school years )

Kind regards.

Rohantha Gunaratna.

PS.

I will look forward to anyone’s comments .

     ********************

HEREWITH SOME INITIAL COMMENTS

Email Note from Mo Marikar [a Trinitian from yesteryeaer], 2 December 2023:

Reading about the past is key to not repeating mistakes. Michael Roberts is a Historian, with a first Class from the U of Ceylon and an earned doctorate from a well established Australian U.
A medium where disparate views can be shared is doing a public service.
Agreeing to disagree is a sign of a people’s maturity……. Mo Marikar
Email Note from Nandasiri Jasentuliyana in USA, 2 December 2023:
“Micheël Roberts is a Rhodes Scholar among a handful of brilliant scholars in the world (see Wikipedia) and a PhD from Oxford.
Email Note from Daya Somasundarm in Australia, 2 Decëmber 2023:
“I would very much agree that unless we learn and understand our past we will continue in the same path as we can easily see that we continue with the very same basic attitudes and perceptions that fueled the wars. Not only in Sri Lanka but elsewhere in the world, Israel, Ukraine… ….. The very same ethnic consciousness.
Email Note from Darini Rajasingham-Senanayake, 2 December 2023
Dear all, …. Agree with many of the arguments here. At the end of the day the “ethnic conflict” was part of a wider regional Cold War proxy war in South Asia, and was part of the colonial strategy to divide and control Ceylon as a British Dominion / later Sri Lanka between the US-UK western block allied with JRJ agains India then allied with the USSR/Russia.
India feared that the US would set up military bases in Trincomalee under JRJ after SWRD nationalized the ports and airports of Sri Lanka and signed his death warrant. US-UK then went to the Chagos Islands, drove out its people and set up a massive Diego Garcia military base there in the early sixties having lost their positions in strategic Lanka.
 We need to be talking about GEOPOLITICAL ECONOMICS!.
Today the memorialization and endless re-hash of ethnic and religious conflicts and history is a ‘beggars wound’  to divide and Distract from Geopolitical economics, which is funded by various donors and NGOs who claim to love Human Rights but do nothing about the carnage in Gaza, Palestine.
In the context I am sharing an article on “CoP 28 as Climate Colonialism” herewith at the link below
https://www.lankaweb.com/news/items/2023/12/02/climate-colonialism-at-cop-28-carbon-laundering-via-green-bondscams/
Enjoy the read and have a great day!”…………………. DRS

ALSO NOTE …. Apropos Darini’s Note

* https://thuppahis.com/2020/06/04/usa-as-worlds-policeman-1945-2020/
* https://thuppahis.com/2018/10/07/diego-garcia-and-the-fate-of-its-its-indigenized-chagossian-people/
Exit mobile version